After in a crowdfunding campaign that ended in June 2024, Studio Camelia, the developer of "a vibrant tribute to the golden age of JPRGs" called Alzara Radiant Echoes, has announced [[link]] that it's shutting down.
In a (via ), Studio Camelia said that despite the success of the crowdfunding campaign, it's been unable to secure further financing and thus cannot continue development.
"We started the studio with our personal savings and managed to convince business angels, banks, and institutions who believed in our vision and supported us," the dev team wrote. "We were even honored to be accepted into Microsoft’s Developer Acceleration Program.
Studio Camelia said it went to Kickstarter to help reduce that perceived risk by demonstrating the level of interest in the game, and the campaign was indeed a major success, pulling in nearly triple its €100,000 ($115,000) goal over a 31 day campaign and becoming one of the biggest videogame Kickstarters of 2024.
And that's where things get a little hairy: Those funds were apparently used to develop a new demo for Alzara, which the studio showed to potential partners at various conferences—none of which resulted in a deal. With no prospect of further funding, the studio was formally liquidated on April 28, and Alzara Radiant Echoes is now "on an indefinite pause."
There's a "slim chance" Alzara might eventually see the light of day if a third party offers to take it over, Studio Camelia wrote, although that would mean the game "would inevitably take a different direction than what was presented during the campaign." For now, though, Kickstarter backers are simply out of luck. There will be no refunds offered, because there is no money to pay for [[link]] them—if there was, the project wouldn't have to be cancelled.
Backers are, understandably, not happy. There are numerous angry complaints that the Kickstarter campaign said nothing about using the funds to develop a demo that would be used to secure even more funding, which as far as I can tell is accurate.
The only hint that the campaign was actually intended to facilitate further fundraising is a line in the saying the studio opted for Kickstarter "to showcase the demand for Alzara Radiant Echoes," rather than to, y'know, make the game.
But the campaign also claimed that Studio Camelia had "meticulously planned every aspect of the game's development to adhere to strict budgets and timelines," strongly implying that those fundamentals were already in place.
There's also clear upset among backers over the fact that the Kickstarter campaign raised triple its goal—these things aren't linear but if you could do what needed to be done with €100K, you should be able to do it really easily with €300K, right?—and that there was no hint of possible problems or financial issues prior to the studio closure announcement. In fact, [[link]] a indicates Studio Camelia was continuing to take "late pledges" until February 17, just a couple months before its closure and liquidation.
Some complained that they won't even get to play the demo that was made with the Kickstarter funds: Studio Camelia released a "pre-production demo" video showing excerpts of demo gameplay but said the demo itself "cannot be shared publicly for copyright reasons, and the company’s liquidation prevents us from releasing any game content."
"I'm honestly at a bit of a loss here," one backer wrote. "I backed this project thinking it was for a complete game, and something that already seemed well along in development. But after reading the latest update and watching the video, I’m left confused. There’s no real demo to speak of, just disjointed snippets of gameplay. And to make matters worse, the gameplay quality is actually lower than what is shown in the GIFs used in the campaign, which now feel more like short animations with a UI layer on top.
"I would have expected significantly more progress after a year. From what was shown in the video, it seems like most of the assets were already in place during the campaign, with maybe a few minor additions. Honestly, it just doesn't add up. It feels like the funding may have been used for things completely unrelated to what was promised, not even to build this demo, which we can’t see or play ourselves."
It's really not hard to understand where the anger is coming from. Alzara's presentation looks fully formed and fleshed out with gameplay clips, animations, character details, and promised collaboration with composer Motoi Sakuraba and character artist Yoshiro Ambe. Nothing about it, as far as I can see—aside from that one little bit in the FAQ—points to this being anything beyond a straight-up "give us money so we can make our game."
I'm pretty pro-Kickstarter overall: I've backed quite a few campaigns over the years, and thus far all but one have worked out. (Even the one that didn't work out was released, it just .) But they are always a risk, even when they look like sure things, and the ugly failure of Alzara Radiant Echoes is a reminder we haven't had for a while: Never put more into a Kickstarter than you can afford to lose without hurting, because there's always a non-zero chance that you might just lose it all.